| 1811-1812 | John Kiersted | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1813 | Asa Bigelow | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1814 | Jacob Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1815 | Jacob Trumpbour, Jr. | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1816 | Jacob Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1817 | Abram Fiero, Jr. | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1818-1819 | Jacob Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1820-1821 | Giles Isham | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1822-1824 | George A. Gay | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1825-1828 | Jeremiah Russell | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1829 | George A. Gay | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1830-1833 | Jeremiah Russell | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1834 | Henry O. Hermance | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1835-1836 | George A. Gay | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1837-1840 | Jeremiah Russell | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1841 | Herman J. Quackenboss | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1842-1843 | Nicholas Shultus | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1844-1845 | John V. L. Overbagh | Whig (NYS Leg. 1840) | Notes? | Image? |
| 1846-1847 | James Russell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1848 | George A. Gay | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1849 | Solomon A. Smith | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1850 | William S. Burhans | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1851 | Nathan Kellogg | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1852 | Solomon A. Smith | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1853 | Fordyce Luther Laflin | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1854 | Peter B. Myer | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1855 | Samuel M. Post | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1856 | William F. Russell | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1857 | Fordyce Luther Laflin | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1858 | Seaman G. Searing | Democratic (NYS Leg. 1878) | Notes? | Image? |
| 1859 | Thomas S. Dawes | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1860 | Fordyce Luther Laflin | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1861 | Thomas S. Dawes | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1862-1864 | Cyrenus F. Brill | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1865-1866 | Fordyce Luther Laflin | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1867 | Nathan Kellogg | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1868-1869 | Jeremiah P. Russell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1867 | Herman Weinans | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1871 | Thomas Maxwell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1872 | John Maxwell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1873 | Robert A. Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1874 | Thomas Maxwell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1875 | Thomas S. Dawes | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1876 | Robert A. Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1877-1878 | Seaman G. Searing | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1879 | Robert A. Snyder | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1880 | Egbert Cooper | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1881-1884 | Uriah Van Etten | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1885 | Albert Carnright | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1886-1889 | Uriah Van Etten | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1890-1892 | Edmund M. WIlbur | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1893-1897 | John D. Fratsher | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1898-1899 | Edmund M. Wilbur | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1900-1907 | D.W. Maxwell | Party? | Notes? | Image? |
| 1908-1913 | John A. Snyder | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1914-1924 | John D. Fratsher | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1924-1930 | John C. Shults | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1930-1934 | Henry A. Lamouree | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1934-1936 | John C. Shults | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1936-1940 | Robert A. Snyder (2) | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1940-1950 | Jacob H. Rogers | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1950-1968 | Peter M. Williams | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1968-1976 | A. Michael Schovel | Democratic (1968), Independent (1976) | Notes? | Image? |
| 1976-1978 | Frank Greco | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1980-1982 | Richard F. Thornton | Democratic, Conservative | Notes? | Image? |
| 1982-1986 | George A. Turner | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 1986-1988 | Gloria Schovel | Democratic, Conservative | Notes? | Image? |
| 1988-1990 | Mike Sommers | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1990-1992 | Vernon Benjamin | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |
| 1992-1994 | George J. Terpening | Conservative | Notes? | Image? |
| 1994-2000 | James R. Griffis | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 2000-2012 | Greg Helsmoortel | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 2012-2014 | Kelly Myers | Republican | Notes? | Image? |
| 2014-2018 | Greg Helsmoortel | Independent | Note: Endorsed by Dem and WFP in 2014-2018 | Image? |
| 2018-2022 | Fred Costello | Democratic | Notes? | Image? |